When it comes to lip balms, the options seem endless—from luxury brands to drugstore favorites.

It’s surprising how similar some formulas can feel despite the price difference. While high-end options may stand out for packaging and scent, affordable alternatives can perform just as well. Here’s a comparison of two lip balms that deliver soft, nourished lips at very different price points.

1. Glossier Birthday Balm Dotcom

This lip balm is a longtime favorite for good reason. Glossier’s Birthday Balm Dotcom combines a nostalgic vanilla scent with a subtle shimmer that makes lips look naturally glowy. The texture is thick enough to feel protective but not sticky, leaving behind a smooth and slightly glossy finish. It’s great for locking in moisture and keeping lips soft throughout the day.

2. E.l.f. Ride or Die Lip Balm

This drugstore gem proves that affordability doesn’t mean sacrificing quality. The e.l.f. Ride or Die Lip Balm delivers a similar level of hydration and shine to pricier alternatives. The texture is rich and cushiony, creating a protective layer that keeps lips soft for hours. One of the best parts is the color payoff—some shades add a hint of tint that flatters the lips beautifully.

When it comes to lip care, it’s not always about the price tag. Glossier’s Birthday Balm Dotcom feels indulgent and playful, while e.l.f.’s Ride or Die Lip Balm delivers excellent hydration and shine without stretching your budget. Both options prove that hydrated, glossy lips can be achieved whether you prefer a luxury treat or a budget-friendly find. In the end, it all comes down to what you value most—brand appeal or a great formula that simply gets the job done.